PBS Hawaiʻi Presents
When Silence Becomes the Song
Special | 58m 45sVideo has Closed Captions
When Silence Becomes the Song
When Silence Becomes the Song
PBS Hawaiʻi Presents is a local public television program presented by PBS Hawai'i
PBS Hawaiʻi Presents
When Silence Becomes the Song
Special | 58m 45sVideo has Closed Captions
When Silence Becomes the Song
How to Watch PBS Hawaiʻi Presents
PBS Hawaiʻi Presents is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Narrator: In the symphony of Life, every being has its part to play.
Every piece of the world in harmonious array.
But among various realms where existence finds its voice, many have gone silent without freedom of choice.
As each beat echoes fainter and balance starts to sway, the remaining must rally to keep chaos at bay.
The journey demands resilience as much will be faced.
But without their effort, what will be heard filling the space?
Pilot (on airplane PA system): Flight attendants, prepare for landing.
Music Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: My name is Ella Marcil.
I grew up on the island of Kauaʻi.
I left for college to pursue a career in filmmaking at the University of Cincinnati, but I'm returning home to Hawaiʻi for spring break because of an emergency call.
The ‘akikiki, a Hawaiian honeycreeper, is about to go extinct, and I've been asked to document the remaining individuals.
I've got no time to waste and I'm on my way to meet up with the team.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Very nice to see you!
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Very nice to see you too.
How was your flight?
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Long!
It was very long, but I'm happy to be home again.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Cool!
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The ʻakikiki is a honeycreeper species unique to the island of Kauaʻi, Hawaiʻi.
Characterized by its small size and muted gray and white plumage, it stands in contrast to the vibrant colors of other Hawaiian forest birds.
For millions of years, these small birds have played a vital part of the natural environment as insect population controllers, allowing trees to flourish.
But the ‘akikiki now faces threats such as habitat loss and introduced predators, pushing them towards extinction.
Once again, thank you so much for picking me up.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Of course!
I'm glad you made it safe.
Sorry it was a long flight.
Twelve hours is brutal but… Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: You know at this point, it's just coffee, coffee and adrenaline keeping me going.
But it's not over yet.
We still got to go to Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery headquarters.
How's your week been?
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: It's been great.
The weather has been a little bit interesting, a little crazy.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Recently, a family of ‘akikiki has been discovered.
They are referred to as the Pele nest, and videographer Graham and I are set to hike tomorrow to find them.
The nest is located in the Alakaʻi Plateau, next to Mount Waiʻaleʻale, one of the wettest spots on Earth.
Graham Talaber: Wildlife Photographer: Hopefully, it will be decent weather when we head up there.
But the winds have been out of the west.
West southwest.
So, It's definitely not usual.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Global climate change has modified the weather patterns of many regions of the world, and Kauaʻi is no exception.
Just a few years back, Kauaʻi set a national record of 50 inches of rainfall in a 24-hour period.
The weather over the last few days has been unusually windy, causing heightened concern among the team for the safety of the Pele nest.
As we make our way towards Hanapēpē, where the Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project headquarters are located, I'm reminded of the island’s unique flora and fauna.
Hawaiʻi has over 10,000 species found nowhere else on Earth.
For millions of years, the evolution of new species vastly exceeded losses due to extinction.
However, after the arrival of humans to the islands, roughly a thousand years ago, numerous extinctions have occurred, and many more species are threatened.
As a result, Hawaiʻi is now referred to by many as the "extinction capital of the world".
Graham Talaber: Wildlife Photographer: One, it's upsetting to lose species that haven't even been described by science, or named by science.
It's even more upsetting to lose species just that, you know, no one's ever photographed, no one even knows existed in the first place.
So I'd like to focus on those marginalized, under-represented species, very much like the ‘akikiki, a little gray bird that doesn't get a whole lot of love, you know.
Little gray birds don't often make the cut.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: You know, the ʻakikiki are very cute.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: They are incredibly cute.
Music: Katie Temple/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: So I'll start you out with looking at the map of one of our field sites, Mohihi, where you're going.
These maps have been invaluable for us.
When I started, they were not this defined, so we would run into waterfalls routinely before… Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: After dropping me off at KFBRP, Graham went home to finish preparing for tomorrow's hike.
Katie, a graduate student, and member of the Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project is going over safety procedures with me, as well as maps of the area that I will be traversing tomorrow.
The Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project is a collaborative effort between the University of Hawaiʻi, the state Department of Land and Natural Resources, and the Division of Forestry and Wildlife.
They aim to promote knowledge, appreciation, and conservation of Kauaʻi's native forest birds.
Their current mission is focused on the ‘akikiki, as their populations have dropped from 1,000 in 2010, to a staggering 40 individuals in present time.
KFBRP has a two-part plan.
The first is to collect all ‘akikiki eggs, chicks, and adults they can find, and the second is to bring those eggs, chicks, and adults into conservation breeding, to provide an insurance population against immediate extinction.
Most people think of Hawaiʻi as this place of sun and warmth.
The Alakaʻi wilderness could not be more different.
There, it rains pretty much every day, and with nighttime and early morning temperatures dropping close to the freezing point, hypothermia is a real concern should someone get lost.
But for many on the team, it's all worth it for these birds.
Justin Hite/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: I’m Justin Hite, with Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Justin Hite is the field supervisor at the Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project for over eight and a half years.
His job includes working with the field crews, making sure that they can get in and out of the field safely, and that they know how to navigate and find the birds, as well as band them.
Coordinating and planning everything so that humans stay safe while helping critically endangered birds is a huge task.
Dr. Cali Crampton is the project manager at Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project.
That's exactly what she does.
Cali Crampton/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project Manager: So you can see, my life is like Tetris, trying to get everything to fit together so that we have the coverage we need to do all the ongoing nest monitoring that we need to do.
So we need to have a constant presence in the field, so we can be always updating whether a nest has laid, or whether chicks have hatched, or whatever yes, because all of our timing of the collections is based on the biology of the bird.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Cali keeps track of every team member using spreadsheets, but she also monitors the birds and their nests.
Because of avian malaria, a disease transmitted by invasive mosquitoes, the ‘akikiki populations have collapsed catastrophically in the last few years.
Her goal is to identify and transfer all of them to conservation centers where they'll be kept safe until their natural habitat has been restored.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: In the future, what does it look like for them?
Cali Crampton/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project Manager: So if our egg collection goes well, and if the mosquito trajectories continue the way they have been going, ‘akikiki will be extinct in the wild this year.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Okay.
Cali Crampton/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project Manager: So, or, at least, there might be an ʻakikiki out there, so not like technically 100% extinct, but as far as being able to be a functioning population that can breed and recover, they are actually already almost extinct in the wild.
Like there's just not enough of them to really rebuild from here and we expect things to get a lot worse with the mosquito trends we are seeing.
So rather than letting mosquitoes take them, we are taking them, so we can put them in safety, in human managed facilities where there are no mosquitoes.
And it has to be done this spring for two reasons.
First of all, we have much better success catching ‘akikiki when they're in breeding mode, and they're territorial, and they're responding to playback.
But also because if we let another fall go by, there might not be enough ‘akikiki left to collect.
So it’s kind of a now or never.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Clearly, this conservation project needs to happen now.
Meeting passionate scientists like Cali gives me hope that we will be able to put up a good fight for the survival of these rare endemic birds.
Cali Crampton/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project Manager: I think for me, what keeps me going is the birds don't give up.
There's still out there making their babies, finding their mates, getting their meal.
They don't give up so we can't.
We can't until the last bird does.
And I just, that's my daily thought.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: I'm part of a media team that's been set up to document the ‘akikiki conservation effort.
We've already had several Zoom calls in the past six months, and this is our last chance to coordinate and finalize before heading up tomorrow.
Juliana will be producing a short film called “Realm of the Gods,” with Sterling and Makenna's help.
We will share footage and assets of our respective projects, but Graham will be the main videographer for filming the birds in the wild.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Yeah, no, I'm really hoping that these cameras can work because I've just been hearing a lot about the weather conditions, and it's intense rain, intense cold, and I've heard this is where electronics come to die.
So, I just want to be prepared... Because sleeping accommodation in the field is limited, the plan, as it stands right now, is to have Graham and I hike up tomorrow.
We will be with the KFBRP team for a week.
Then, as we hike down, Juliana, Sterling, and Makenna will go up.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: All right, bye.
Thanks everyone.
Thank you.
Today's stories are captured behind the lenses of cameras.
Back in ancient Hawaiʻi however, stories and life lessons were preserved through song and dance.
As a blessing for this project, the Ka ‘Imi Hula Halau created a mele called "Na Manu ‘Ehā".
This hula describes four of Hawaiʻi's endangered forest birds, including the ‘akikiki.
Music/Singing Na Manu ʻEhā in Hawaiian: Ai, Na Manu ʻEhā Lele aʻe ka ʻākohekohe i kiʻekiʻe o Waiakamoi hulu aʻeaʻe aʻehu pua i ke poʻo pūpū kīnohi la Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: In Hawaiʻi, birds are seen as ‘aumakua, or guardian spirits.
Their feathers were highly valued by ancient Hawaiian nobility and meticulously crafted into various ceremonial items such as feather leis, helmets, feather standards, and feather capes.
Bird catchers would line branches of trees with sticky sap for honeycreepers that would land on them, becoming ensnared.
Then, with utmost care, only one to three feathers from the neck, wing or tail were removed before releasing the bird back into the forest.
The intricate process of harvesting feathers meant that numerous birds, often exceeding 20,000, were required to produce a single feather garment.
Music/Singing Na Manu ʻEhā in Hawaiian: Ua kapalili ʻo ʻakekeʻe pūnana ʻia i Mōhihi mele maʻo me he makakiʻ ʻōkiki mū ʻana i ka pāʻina Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: These forest birds play a crucial role in shaping Hawaiʻi's identity.
Unfortunately, only eight of Kauaʻi's original two dozen species remain today.
Preserving and protecting these remaining few is paramount,not only for the conservation of a unique part of Hawaiʻi's natural heritage, but also for maintaining the cultural and ecological balance that these birds contribute to the islands.
Music ends/Last line of song Na Manu ʻEhā: Ai e hoʻoheno i nā manu ʻehā Music: Graham Talaber/Wildllife Photographer: So it's a gorgeous day today, but I guess the winds must have been bad enough to knock, knock the Pele nest down.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Just as feared, yesterday's unusual winds knocked down the Pele nest the team was scheduled to collect tomorrow.
Both chicks were killed, and the parents have flown away.
We're still heading to meet the rest of the team, but we're not sure of what's next.
Music: Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Trailʻs up here through these trees.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Up there?
Music/Ku'u Lei 'Awapuhi: Auhea la ′oe ke aloha Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The Alakaʻi Wilderness Preserve is a 9,000-acre secluded area at the very center of the island.
It is administered by the State of Hawaiʻi's Department of Land and Natural Resources.
The journey to access the Alakaʻi Plateau requires passage through steep ridges, separated by ravines and gullies.
Mōhihi Camp, where Graham and I are headed, is one of the most remote locations the KFBRP team has established for the ‘akikiki conservation project.
The camp is just steps away from a cliff that drops more than a thousand feet down.
Music/Kuʻu Lei ʻAwapuhi: E ku'u aloha e (e′ō) ′Auhea la 'oe (eia mai au) A huli aku au iā ′oe Instrumental music continues: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: It's incredible to think that there were 50 mph winds here yesterday.
I'm very lucky the weather was on our side because this hike has been the longest and most difficult one I've ever experienced.
As we approach Mōhihi Camp, the first person we encounter is Justin as he's setting up for the night.
We finally made it.
So nice to finally meet you.
Justin Hite/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Yeah, you too.
Music/Kuʻu Lei ʻAwapuhi: Auhea la ′oe ke aloha Awapuhi pala o ka ua noe Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Most of the equipment and food were dropped off by helicopter about a week ago.
The cases were then hauled from the landing site to camp.
I’m grateful that others were willing to do this because now I have the tools I need to do my part in this project.
As the day ends, everyone is beginning to settle down for the night.
Some people will be sleeping in their own tents.
Others will be sharing the communal tent that's a little further away from the edge of the cliff.
As for me, because all sleeping spots were already taken, I was assigned to sleep in the tent where all the food and equipment is stored.
The nights are cold here, so it's a good thing I came prepared.
Music/Kuʻu Lei ʻAwapuhi: 'Auhea la ′oe (eia mai au) A huli aku au iā 'oe A huli aku au iā 'oe A huli aku au iā ′oe Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: All the required equipment to collect the ‘akikiki chicks was brought to the Pele nest before it fell.
Since everyone and everything is here, Justin thought it could be a great learning opportunity to practice egg and chick collection.
‘Akikiki birds build their nests high up in the crowns of trees where predators cannot get to them, making the collection process difficult and risky.
Team member: Good!
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Cool!
Thank you.
Team member: Okay, anything else that I’m not thinking of before I come down?
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Now that there are no other birds or eggs to collect, people will go scout the forest.
I’m heading back to Mōhihi Camp to grab some extra gear.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Mōhihi Camp was expanded and provisioned for this conservation project just a few weeks ago.
Apart from satellite and occasional cellular reception, it is completely off the grid.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Rainwater is filtered and used for cooking and drinking.
A solar panel was installed on the edge of the cliff, but it often fails and cannot really be dependent on to charge batteries or electronic devices.
When KFBRP is done researching and saving birds in the area, the camp will be dismantled, and nothing will be left behind.
At night, we all gather around here, breakfast time, lunch, gather around, make some delicious hot chocolate, some tea, cook some eggs, cook some pasta, and just sit around on these, get a bucket if you can grab one, just eat, talk story, and talk about the progress of the day, and what went on.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The forest is incredibly beautiful and covered everywhere in a thick velvety moss.
Even on camp, numerous birds can be heard and spotted fluttering across the sky.
I have brought several different cameras and hope to catch a honeycreeper on film.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Kauaʻi was once home to over two dozen forest birds.
Of the eight that still remain, three are on the brink of extinction, the ʻakekeʻe, the puaiohi, and the ʻakikiki.
The bird I'm following is an ‘anianiau, the smallest Hawaiian honeycreeper in existence today.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: It's a very rare site and quite a challenge to film.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: These little forest birds are extremely fast, and constantly on the move foraging for food.
So getting a good shot isn't easy.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Hey Brendan!
Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Hey!
Howzit going?
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Good, good.
I was just following and filming a bird.
Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Nice.
I just found an ‘akikiki nest, just downstream, the Pakele's re-nest.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Yeah?
Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: She's banded aluminum, orange, orange, orange.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Wait, what was her name?
Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Pakele.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Pakele.
Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Just found her nest just 5 minutes ago.
I'm like buzzing right now.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The team is finally back together at camp.
Based on today's findings, it was decided that the larger part of our group will be moving out north tomorrow morning to the Upper Upper Camp.
Graham and I will stay here and continue our work at Mōhihi, alongside Brendan and Bow.
This has been an amazing first day.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Today, the weather is once again beautiful, and Graham has agreed to take me to Pigsjaw, an area of the Alakaʻi Plateau he was scouting yesterday.
It's a couple of miles to the southeast and getting to it requires hiking through rough terrain.
There's still a lot of water and mud everywhere, and the vegetation is dense, sometimes hiding big drops.
Many have experienced mishaps on these trails and had to be rescued.
Or, worse.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: ʻAkikiki eat insects and worms which they find by pecking and pulling at the bark of snags and tree trunks of species such as ʻōhiʻā and ʻōlapa.
They often favor tall trees that offer a lot of foraging trunk, so this is exactly where we are looking for them.
They are usually seen traveling and foraging in pairs, or in family groups.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: ‘Akikiki only produce a brood of one to two eggs per year because of the long juvenile dependency period.
Like other Hawaiian honeycreepers, juvenile ʻakikiki may stay with their parents for up to three months after fledging.
Identifying them by sight is far easier than identifying them by sound, as ʻakikiki sound much like the ‘akekeʻe, ‘anianiau and Kauaʻi ‘amakihi.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: This is kind of my, this is my technique for coming out here to this area.
It's just super slowly, walking around.
It's pretty mild, it's flat.
You just cruise around and hope that something reveals itself, and then shoot.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The first bird we spot is the iconic ʻiʻiwi, with its bright scarlet feathers, black wings and tail, and long decurved pink bill.
We also see the ‘anianiau, my little friend from yesterday.
The secretive and rare puaiohi.
The ʻakekeʻe, the second most endangered endemic Hawaiʻi bird after the ʻakikiki.
The ʻelepaio, with its long tail, which is regularly held up at an angle.
The ʻapapane, an important ʻōhiʻā pollinator.
The ʻamakihi, a honeycreeper that feeds on insects, nectar, and fruit.
And at last, the bird we came to rescue, the ʻakikiki.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: There's a couple that keeps flying up above our heads.
So it's really cool.
Saw a couple of ʻiʻiwi gathered around together in the distance out there.
You see that Graham is out filming.
He looks really happy right now.
I can tell by the smile on his face.
So, yeah, everyone is just chilling, and just been very calm, and relaxing, and appreciative, and happy to be here with all these birds.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: On this clear calm day, the forest is filled with songs that have had been sung for over five million years.
Many of the now extinct Hawaiian forest birds were never photographed, filmed, or recorded.
In a time where some of these ancient voices still sing, we have the opportunity to hear their song, ensuring that future generations know what these remaining birds look and sound like.
NATURAL SOUND OF BIRDS: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: I will never forget my day at Pigsjaw, and its unusual name, derived from the topography of the plateau, which resembles a pig’s jaw.
Local hunters often roam these mountains.
As a distinctive marker, they've placed a pig’s jaw at the junction of Pigsjaw to signify the location.
This startling sight couldn't be in more contrast with how peaceful and beautiful everything is.
Invasive goats and feral pigs are unfortunately everywhere in the forest these days, wreaking havoc on natural ecosystems by devouring and dispersing fruits of invasive plants, like strawberry guava.
The appetite of invasive goats also extends to rare endemic plants, further damaging the ecosystem.
Additionally, pigs contribute to the decline of honeycreeper species by creating wallows that serve as breeding grounds for mosquitoes.
In pre-contact Hawaiʻi, the Alakaʻi was part of what ancient Hawaiians called Wao Akua, or Realm of the Gods.
This was a very sacred place, rarely accessed by humans.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: All right, finally made it.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: High five!
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Finally made it back.
Okay, I know Brendan's not going back until like five, five thirty-ish, so I'm gonna get started on dinner.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Cool!
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Yeah!
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: I'm just going to chill out and I'll help you with dinner.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Awesome.
Thank you so much for showing me around the area on the Alakaʻi.
This was a really beautiful day, to go out there.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Yeah, right?
This was definitely one for the books.
All eight forest birds in a day.
It's a pretty good thing to do.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: It was so close, up close and personal.
That was, that was insane.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Yeah.
Well, thank you.
You're great company.
Team member: To get to the far nest, but there are a couple territories that we can get to… Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: As night falls and everyone returns to camp, Brendan is setting up rat traps as they tend to roam at night in search of food.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: What UV, what fluoresces under UV light.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Meanwhile, Graham is exploring the area for animal and plant species that are still unknown to science.
It’s purple!
He has brought his UV flashlight, and I'm tagging along.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Look at how bright it glows!
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Yeah.
Hang on, let me… Feels like Avatar in here.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Right?
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: I love that ruby pink.
Under the glow of ultraviolet light, everything looks different.
This helps biologists and conservationists see things they wouldn't normally see at night.
Team member: What was that?
Team member: There's a rat!
Look at the rat glowing.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Oh my God!
Got to shove a rat trap in there.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: It's a Kauaʻi endemic.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Even though Graham's initial passion is for botany and rare plants, his knowledge of invertebrates is vast.
Although this trip is to rescue a bird from extinction, endemic Hawaiian invertebrates constitute the vast majority of species that are now going extinct in the state.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Oh my God!
We need to get my camera.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Is he something new?
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photogrpaher: It looks like it's doryonychus raptor, but it's a little different, and we're way out of doryonychus range here.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Just like when he was filming the ʻakikiki earlier today, Graham gets incredibly focused when he's in the presence of something rare, unique, or unknown.
His passion is undeniably obvious, and quite contagious.
His photos are simply amazing, and I feel inspired by his work.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: So I know everyone else has gone to bed for the night, but I wanted to hear more about the Livermore, in California, story.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Um yeah.
So Livermore is where I grew up in the East Bay Area, in California.
And I grew up there, rode my bike around with my friends lots when I was younger.
And as I got older, I went to college at the University of Oregon, and I started getting really into botany, particularly rare plants, and endangered plants.
And sure enough, as I graduated college, I moved back from Oregon, back to Livermore.
It became apparent to me that there was actually tons of rare plants all around me in the Bay Area, even in Livermore.
This one place in particular, we used to call the Wasteland, it's one of these little abandoned fields where we used to ride our bikes.
Turns out it’s actually one of the rarest ecosystems, rarest ecologies, anywhere in the world.
The greater threat in California, especially in this area, is development.
With, you know, increase in people, there's this huge push for development, huge push for more houses or living spaces for people.
And soon after I moved back to California, and I was just in the peak of my geeking out over plants phase over there, I realized that there was a 42-acre development proposed for this hill that's kind of in the middle of this flat land.
I was like, “Hold up.” Like, “There's a ton of things here you guys aren't considering.” So I went nuts, photographing the rare plants that live there.
And that's basically what we did.
We kind of brought that to light, and we worked with this legal team, and after years of legal stuff, finally, we won in the Supreme Court, which is pretty awesome.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: In the Supreme Court?
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: And our case set precedence, and it changed how California is supposed to handle developments in the future basically.
Yeah, it's kind of, it was a really special situation, really cool experience.
And then that's kind of what got me into thinking, “Oh there is like a use for me,” like wasting endless hours, and gas, driving around.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Graham's story reminds me that anyone, regardless of their background, holds the power to make a positive impact in their community.
By channeling their strengths and passions, individuals contribute to the betterment of the places they, and others, call home.
The animal and plant species found in Graham's local hometown are just as significant as the ʻakikiki.
If people take action on local issues, then collectively, we can set into motion collaborative efforts that can then have a global impact.
Rain falling: Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: It's really sad, but I mean it's, it's killing a life to save a life ‘cause they're very invasive, and they're eating the birds alive, and the eggs.
So you do what you can.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Today, the Alakaʻi is living up to its reputation for being wet, very wet.
Although these weather conditions make it difficult to see or hear ʻakikiki in the wild, Brendan is leading us further down into Pigsjaw, in search of new individuals.
The goal is to remove all ʻakikiki to protect them from mosquitoes, but finding them on a day like today is like finding a needle in a haystack.
We occasionally hear vocalizations that resemble those of the ʻakikiki, but so far, we've had no luck.
Music: Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: The thing that people say is that the ʻakikiki will switch between the up slur and the normal note, more than say, like ‘ani will either keep doing the up slur, or keep doing the single note.
But that's like not like proven, or anything, but that's one thing people say.
And, I don't know, ʻakikiki just seem to like always just, like be whispering, until they fly, because they're always so close together, and then when one flies off far, they'll be like “Chip Chip Chip”, and then others, like, oh okay.
But usually, they're just like really kind of like gentle.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: After unsuccessfully searching for more than five hours and covering a huge area of the plateau, Brendan has decided to take us to the nest he discovered a few days ago, to see how things are going.
The rain has receded, but we're still soaked to the bone.
But that's not the concern right now.
Once again, there are no ʻakikiki in sight, which has everyone quite worried.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: After waiting almost an hour for one of the adults to return, Brendan has decided to peep the nest, which means looking inside of it via a camera attached to a long pole.
Music: Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Okay.
Can you, can you take a screenshot, right there?
I think it died.
It's just like, normally it would be like kind of sitting up.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Hmmm, he's face down.
What a shame.
And the other egg is right there.
Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: There's only one nest in there, but yeah, it does not look alive and… Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: At this very early stage of their lives, birds require the constant presence of their parents both to feed them, and to keep them warm.
This chick and egg have died because their parents have abandoned the nest, giving the team an even smaller population to rescue.
Although we don't know why this nest has failed for certain, multiple factors have played a role in the decline of forest bird populations.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The displacement of native plant species by invasive counterparts has brought profound changes on the forest structure and composition.
This alteration has been felt throughout the ecosystem, impacting animal habitats, foraging patterns, nesting sites, and hydrological dynamics.
Historically, the landscape transformation began with the arrival of Polynesians who cleared extensive lowland areas for agricultural purposes.
The trend was accentuated by westerners in the 1800’s, exacerbating deforestation for ranching, developmental projects, and the exploitation of valuable timber species, such as koa and sandalwood.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Introduced predators, such as cats, not only prey on endemic birds, but also pass on these hunting skills to their offspring.
Rats, the second largest threat to endemic birds also impact honeycreepers in a variety of ways.
They raid nests, consuming eggs, chicks, and nesting females, and they compete with native birds for food resources like fruit and invertebrates.
The deadliest threat however, comes in the form of avian malaria, transmitted by introduced mosquitoes.
Although these endemic bird species spent millions of years evolving, they have not been able to evolve fast enough to create an immunity to the diseases carried by mosquitoes.
Before human contact, these forest birds were found from the tip of mountains, all the way down to the ocean shores.
Since the arrival of mosquitoes, they have retreated to higher elevations to find protection in its colder climate.
As climate change progresses however, and temperatures rise, the birds have become trapped.
Mosquitoes have since taken over the area, easily picking the birds off one by one.
And many times, all it takes is one bite.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Yesterday, the other team sent Brendan footage of a nest that was raided by rats.
Today, it’s our turn to share the bad news of what we've discovered.
Once again, plans around the collection of this nest will need to be cancelled.
During our time here in the Alakaʻi, I've seen more dead ʻakikiki than living ones.
This is by far the worst season for failed nests.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Where there's good, there's bad.
As Dolly said: “Everyone wants happiness, nobody wants pain.
But you can't have a rainbow without a little rain.” Person on the phone off camera: Are you okay?
Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Yeah, we're okay.
I just wanted to call and let you know that the pigsjaw’s nest is dead.
Exactly.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: How are you feeling this morning?
Graham Talaber/Wildlilfe Photographer: A-one.
Got a great ʻakekeʻe video before 8:15, and stoked.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Nice!
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: My day’s already made.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The Alakaʻi has become overrun with invasive species, quieting the songs that have been here for millions of years.
Seeing firsthand the devastation, it's evident that invasive species must be removed.
Although traditional rat traps are set around camp, a far more efficient method has been deployed wide scale throughout the forest: the A24.
Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: It's powered by CO2 right here, and it has a bait, lure up here that's scented.
And so, the rats will kind of sniff out the bait and crawl up here.
And then there's a piston that's powered by the CO2, that when it trips this little trip wire, it shoots out a piston and... Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Bioacoustic devices have also been set up around the area that automatically records the birds as they sing.
Researchers working with KFBRP are now training AI tools to distinguish and recognize the various species of birds that live here.
This will in turn help the team identify where birds are, so that they can be more efficient in searching the forest.
Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Here we go!
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: In an effort to combat avian malaria, the state of Hawaiʻi recently initiated the Incompatible Insect Technique, or IIT.
Avian malaria is only spread through the female southern house mosquito.
Male mosquitoes do not bite, and thereby do not transmit diseases to either birds or humans.
The technique breeds incompatible male mosquitoes with female mosquitoes, and results in the females only producing infertile eggs.
This technique has proven to be very effective in other parts of the world, and hopefully, its deployment is not too late to save the species here.
Bret Nainoa Mossman/Natural Resource Management Specialist: As someone who works with these birds every day, I've seen the impacts that the diseases spread by mosquitoes have on these species.
Maimed limbs, missing eyes, even losing their bills because of lesions from pox.
And the slow decline of even the largest and healthiest birds to malaria, to the point where the birds can no longer move, and eventually die.
Malaria has had such an impact, that just as in our history, we nearly lost our language, our native birds are losing theirs.
Leilani Lozi/Hawaiʻi Engagement and Education Manager-Gemini Observatory: I believe that in in order to tackle a lot of the hurdles that we are facing as a society today, we have to trust in our scientists, and in our people who are in the forest, and taking care of these issues every day.
And that sometimes, as a community, we have to trust in each other, and each other's expertise on these things in which they spend their whole life working on.
Cali Crampton/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project Manager: Extinction is not an option.
Not when we have this opportunity.
And we do have no time to waste.
So again, I strongly support the request to approve the final East Maui EA and authorize the chairperson to issue a finding of no significant impact for this important effort to save our birds, and to save our ʻāina.
Thank you.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The importance of the ʻakikiki in this community highlights the necessity of addressing local issues.
Making a difference can look like many things.
Starting a club, wearing a shirt can all be small ways to take action and make a difference.
Getting exposure out to the community is crucial for positive change to happen.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The passion the KFBRP team has is contagious and strengthens my own flame for environmental activism.
Their work shows the significance of preserving all species, not just the popular ones.
Everyone can do something just by managing their climate footprint, and supporting climate friendly initiatives locally, nationally, and globally.
We need only to look to the birds for an example.
They're out there.
If their nest fails, they build a new one.
If their mate dies, they find a new mate, and they build a new nest.
The birds keep going, and while the birds are finding a way to keep going, we will find a way to keep going.
Music/vocalizing: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: And if the message needed to be summarized in just a few words, this is what it would be.
Music: Brendan Wang/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: All right!
See you later guys.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Bye!
And thank you so much Bow for everything.
I've had like an amazing experience here with everyone.
Bow Tyler/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: That's good.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: So hopefully, we'll have a community screening at the Kukui Grove Mall.
So I'd love to see everybody there, like Brendan, everybody.
I'm so excited for it.
Bow Tyler/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: I know, yeah.
And good luck with all your editing.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Thank you again for everything.
Had a great time with you guys.
Bow Tyler/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Yeah, maybe see you soon.
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Yeah!
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: The time has come to return to the Wao Kanaka, the Realm of Humans.
It's been raining all night, and there's a high chance the streams down below are swollen.
Graham and I will hike down the southern trail to save time.
Although we need to hurry, it's hard for us to say goodbye.
See ya!
Bow Tyler/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: Later!
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: It's imperative that we cross the Mōhihi Stream while it's still safe to do so.
Otherwise, we'll be faced with a treacherous retreat back to camp, for which we may not have enough energy to safely complete.
How long do you think until we reach the stream?
Graham Talaber/Wildlife Photographer: Like 3 and 1/2 miles.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: 3 and 1/2 miles.
Okay.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: This is a risky crossing, but hiking back to camp is even riskier at this point.
Even the cameraman has to assist so I don't get swept away.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: My time in the Alakaʻi is now over, but for the rest of the team, the work continues.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Since my return to Cincinnati, KFBRP continues to remove all ʻakikiki eggs, chicks, and adults they can find, and transfer them to conservation centers, where mosquitoes cannot reach them.
It's not over for this species just yet.
There is still hope as some fifty individuals continue to live and breed in captivity.
Other endemic Hawaiian species, like the nēnē, have rebounded from the brink of extinction, and conservationists are hopeful that mosquito control methods, such as IIT, will one day allow them to restore the Alakaʻi Wilderness Preserve to its original state.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: Humans caused the ʻakikiki problem, so humans need to fix it.
It's a long shot, and the odds are against us, but turning a blind eye, or giving up, is not an option.
There are other critically endangered birds that require energy, time, and resources.
They will benefit from the lessons learned with the ʻakikiki.
So work in the field continues to keep the voices of native birds heard.
But as important as the work in the field is, it's just as important to let people know about the fate of these birds.
Music: There are different kinds of outreach events, but the most effective way to bring about change is to share our urgent message with those who hold the power to pass laws and allocate funding.
Cali Crampton/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project Manager: To the crisis that is affecting our birds… Julia Diegmann/Kauaʻi Forest Bird Recovery Project: I think these birds need a voice, and they deserve to be celebrated.
Young speaker testifying on zoom conference call: Kauaʻi honeycreepers definitely keep this ecosystem alive.
Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: A shift is happening with youth at the heart of it.
Grade school student testifying: I think this is important legislation because the native birds of Hawaiʻi are so special.
Grade school student testifying: We are advocating to you, our legislators, to help protect and bring awareness of our native Hawaiʻi forest birds by voting yes on the bill to celebrate Hawaiian Honeycreeper Day.
Group of grade school students speaking together: Please support honeycreeper… Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: This exponential growth in awareness is not only happening in Hawaiʻi, but at national, and international levels.
Music: Ella Marcil/Filmmaker: But as with all global movements, it begins in our own backyard, at the local level, within our own community.
And for the ʻakikiki, these are the heroes keeping their song alive.
Group singing Na Manu ʻEhā: Lele aʻe ka ʻākohekohe i kiʻekiʻe o Waiakamoi hulu aʻeaʻe aʻehu pua i ke poʻo pūpū kīnohi la ʻākohekohe ʻākohekohe Kau i ka ʻiu ke kiwikiu i ka wēkiu o Hanawī ʻōlenalena nā kuʻe maka nuku makili i ka laʻau ke kiwikiu ke kiwikiu Leo leʻa ka ʻakikiki kakaʻikahi ma Halepaʻakai kāhiko ʻia i ka hulu ʻāhina a pili paʻa kona hoa ka ʻakikiki ka ʻakikiki Ua kapalili ʻo ʻakekeʻe pūnana ʻia i Mōhihi mele maʻo me he makakiʻI ʻōkiki mū ʻana i ka pāʻina ʻo ʻakekeʻe ʻo ʻakekeʻe Eō mai e ka lehulehu ʻo ʻākohekohe ʻo kiwikiu ʻo ʻakikiki a ʻo ʻakeke`e e hoʻoheno i nā manu ʻehā nā manu ʻehā nā manu ʻehā
PBS Hawaiʻi Presents is a local public television program presented by PBS Hawai'i